Life Issues
Harriett Asks: To Be A Christian Or Not To Be A Christian
3/8/2012 10:00:26 PM
Dear Dr. Archer,
I am 19 years old, and cannot understand how someone can be perfectly okay with not being a Christian. I want to believe that life is what we make it and that we can shape the future, but Christianity says something completely different. This is causing me much grief and self-doubt. 

Christians believe that the sole purpose of humanity is to serve and love God and to spread the Word. God wants a loving relationship with mankind, but man must first turn away from his sinful nature and repent. 

Christians also believe that true happiness, peace and personal satisfaction comes from a relationship with God. God is all that man needs and earthly things or personal ambitions are bad. How can I take all of this in without going insane? 

I feel bad and inadequate because I don't have a particular religion or a strict moral code. I don't think I believe in the Bible or Jesus at all. I first want solid proof of Jesus’ historical existence before I devote the rest of my life to His religion.

My mom is very devoted to her Christian faith and very involved in the church. She sometimes tells me that I need to get involved and change my ways, but it just makes me angry or scared. 

I want to live my life for myself and make myself happy, not for some spiritual being that I don't know. I don't want to force myself to serve someone that I don't love or care about. But at the same time, I don't want to go to Hell when the time comes. 

As you can see, I have a lot of anxiety about the big questions in life and it's eating me up inside. I could really use some psychological advice and relief!

How do I cope with not knowing the purpose of mankind? Are you spiritual in any way? If yes, why? And is it the only righteous way to live your life? If not, how do you cope with that decision? Especially if you could go to Hell.

I really want to start researching the history of Christianity, the Bible and Jesus to discover the truth. If I am convinced that Christianity is the real deal, then I will learn to commit. 

I know that this will sound pretty bad, but I really hope that religion doesn't exist at all. I don't want any limitations on what I can be or do. There are enough rules in life already. I feel like I'm supposed to have spiritual beliefs and morals, because it makes you a good person. How can I deal with my uncertainties?
Harriett

Dear Harriett,
Everybody wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die. Ahhh, you are tackling a subject which has bothered man since the beginning of time! Friendships have been lost, families torn apart, courts divided, and many, many wars fought, killing millions, over this very subject.

I feel honored you think I have the answers, Harriett. The truth of the matter is that to believe in God, you must have faith in something you cannot prove. Sorry, no proof here. 

As far as physical proof, what we do have from that era is a limestone inscribed with the name Pontius Pilate, who of course, was reportedly responsible for the execution of Jesus. 

World historian Will Durant has painstakingly spent his life studying Hebrew writings and claims no Jew or Gentile from the first century denies the existence of Jesus. In fact, Jesus is a prominent character in the historical writings. Whether he was the Son of God is left up to each individual to decide, but there is much historical data and eye witness accounts from that time, that will be helpful in making your decision. Word Pictures by CrossTV is another source to research for more information.

Christians don’t believe wealth and possessions are always bad things. As with anything, Harriett, wealth can be used for good or evil. It goes deeper into the individual's heart -- do you make money and possessions your god more than focusing on love and compassion for others? 

Money often changes folks for the worst -- the love of money is considered the root of all evil. Money can be used for good, but can also be used for terrible, horrific things. It's basically the attitude toward money that makes the difference.

If there was hard proof, Harriett, this would be a slam dunk - everybody would believe. Jesus was quoted as saying to Thomas, who doubted him, "Because you have seen, you believe. Blessed is he who believes and has not seen." John 20:29 

Whatever your belief, Harriett, it is yours, either through faith or absence of faith. This is a very personal decision that you, yourself must make. What I believe is irrelevant. This is YOU, and YOUR beliefs. Not mine, not your mom's but strictly your own. You hope religion doesn't exist, but it most certainly does, and religious wars are fought every day, even now.

If you find Christianity, you won't learn to commit; you'll want to commit. I think the same can be said for any answer you find that gives you peace from within, whatever that may be. I've given you a few pieces of material to start you on your research, so begin your journey today.

In the meantime, remember that you're not the only person to have all these questions. It means you're thoughtful, and that you take things seriously. Good luck, and when you find your answer, feel free to share them with the rest of us!
Dr. Archer 

Posted by: Dr. Dale Archer | Submit comment | Tell a friend

Categories: Love  |  Self-Esteem Issues  |  Stress  |  Survival

Share and enjoy: Del.icio.us   Digg This   Facebook   Google Bookmarks   Stumble Upon   Windows Live Bookmark   Yahoo Bookmark
13 Comments
3/9/2012 7:02:39 AM
19 is exactly the right age that you should feel you want to have a religion. And this is why you are looking for it Harriett. Read the Bible, find the version which has explanatory comments alongside it. So you will understand everything. I am SURE Harriett that you will be a Christian. Your mother is already lucky to know the truth. And she taught you what she knows. She should not force you however to believe. Study yourself and you will find that Jesus is one part of the Holy Trinity. Because He loves you, He came to the earth. Because He loves you, He gave his blood. He bought us all from death. He paid the price with his own blood and sacrifice. No man exists on earth who won't understand His love, if he knows what His sacrifice was about. If you believe in Him, you will be saved. You can have all the riches in the world and still be a good Christian. In fact, He will preovide you with all the things you need to live here happily. Read the Bible, and this is the only book you'll ever need in life. The only book, you just can't be without. Ask your questions to a priest of your church, and all your answers will be given. You will be happy and won't need to search any longer about the meaning of your life. Remember, our earthy life is only 'seconds', compared to eternal life, which God will give, because He has promised it to us.

Finally, I leave you with this thought: When the Twin Towers were falling... you remember what was the word coming out of people's mouth, who were looking at it in a shock, their husbands or wives were in the towers and were dying at this moment, while they were watching. They screamed and cried out "Jesus Christ''. Let us hope that we won't need to be in such a position, in order to need to call the name of our Lord. This is the only name you'll ever need. He is everything, and made you from nothing. Also, He doesn't need us, but we need Him, in order to ensure we get our next breath. He provides each of our beaths. There is no happiness without Him, or far away from Him. Stay close to Him, and you'll have a caring Father. He will treat you nicely in life, then also redeem you in heaven. You will be happy in both places, no matter what is going on around you. He will be there for you. His name is the most beloved name. The only name you'll call in need. Whether you know it or not, He is the one who will come to save you. He also has saved you a million times already, without you knowing it... And if these words cause you tears, like they caused me, be happy because He is talking to you, asking you to open the door of your heart.
3/9/2012 1:19:03 PM
There are as many religions as there are people. Even within a community of Christians, each person tailors the religion to suit themselves to some extent. I think it's very healthy to question the Bible and to always ponder any beliefs others have formed that they are trying to suggest you adhere to. The Bible was written a very long time ago by all men, isn't theleast bit woman-friendly, and has been amended to suit many rulers in between. Even many religious leaders agree it was at times used as a way for the rulers to control the masses. Is that bad? In its extreme, certainly. But I think we all agree there need to be some basic moral guidelines.

I was brought up in a hellfire and damnation community. We were taught that God was all-powerful, all-knowing, and benevolent. I quickly saw the impossibility of God being all three the first bad thing that happened to me as a child. If God was all-powerful and benevolent, then why is he allowing people and animals to suffer? If he he is all-powerful but not benevolent, then why would I worship him?

There are many many things that don't make sense about what any organized religion teaches, and like Dr. Archer said, we all need to form our own beliefs about that. I know when you're pressured to follow this certain path, it is very hard to even explore your beliefs without being condemned for it, and what I learned is to just keep my hat on around my community and not insult anyone but I soon got outside the community to a larger world where many more beliefs exist and, therefore, much more tolerance.

There are times when I really believe that whatever we believe deep down inside, that is our reality. I basically believe "it is what it is" and that "it" is different for every person. I believe we likely do all have different things influencing us on every level. I cannot possibly believe that any god who was worth worshipping would create a person only to then reject who they are and condemn them to hell for being what he created. Remember, if God created everyone, then he created diversity the world over who all believe different things. To think that only Christians are the privileged ones who will go to a good place after death is the worst kind of self-serving snobbery, in my opinion.

The truth is, we do not know and are not supposed to know what comes after death. There are people of all religions and no religion who commune with spirits, whether it's Jesus or unknown spirits, and I truly believe there are those who do. We have to wonder, though, if we were given a brain, was it ever meant that instead of using it and exploring our own thoughts, we just set those aside and leave it up to whatever dieties there are to work our life for us. I believe that in our lives, we are the most important, most powerful influence on ourselves, and that though there may, if we're lucky, be divine guidance, we are supposed to take responsibility for ourselves and progress on our own power as much as possible for the best possible results.

I recently saw a really succinct quote about the religious debate and would like to share it with you:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dxdgCxK4VUA

Don't be afraid to explore. You have a brain. You can't be expected not to use it.
3/9/2012 10:44:54 PM
Some good advice here Harriet! As Marcia suggested.,talk to a pastor and read (learn) the word. Priests are general theologens. Christian radio or T.V. shows can help you decide. GOD BLess.,Gene
3/10/2012 12:34:30 PM
Thanks Dr. Archer for answering my question! And thanks for the comment Marcia! I'm ready to start my research. It's going to be quite a process, but I'm eager to begin. I've been bothered by my inquiries since I was a little girl. Maybe that was a calling of sorts? I guess I do secretly wish that religion didn't exist. It makes everything so complicated! My toughest challenges will
be to accept the truth and my decision. It's hard for me
to feel any compassion towards religion. All I get from it are lectures about shortcomings, failures and faults. There are a lot of intimidating expections to be followed too! That turns me off instantly, because I'm the type of person who feeds off of kindness, love and empathy. All the church members that I
have listened to or talked to used none of those things.
They just got on people's backs and condemned them. I don't get the slightest a sense of compassion from
that.
3/16/2012 8:22:15 AM
Well, Harriett, people who condemn others, are not really Christians. We are not allowed to condemn others than ourselves. It is very difficult to be forgiving of others, but tough on yourself. This is what they should be doing. However, no one is perfect. We are only born to try!
DDA
3/17/2012 11:47:09 AM
Thank you for sharing that, Lola.
8/3/2012 12:24:09 PM
I sent you a letter some time ago about my concerns with religion and whether it's true or not. I've done some research and read a lot online. I've come to realize that Jesus was in fact a real historical figure ( I know, kinda sad right?). But now I'm faced with another dilemma. I've been
reading about religion in general, not just Christianity and I so far I don't like any of it. Most belief systems seem to be the same. That man is flawed, the world is fallen and the only way to be saved and ascend to perfection, is to fully submit to God and follow a set of practices. The
ultimate prize is eternal life. I'm not sure which direction I should take in my search now. I was thinking about reading the Bible, but I think I'll put it off for now. All the religious stuff that I've read so far has left me feeling upset. I don't really believe in good and evil, I surely don't want to be a servant and I don't agree with eternal reward or puishment. I think I'll need the help of a spiritual teacher on this one. I would really appreciate some direction in my spiritual journey. I'm starting to feel depressed and angry, since physical existence is starting to appear jaded and meaningless.
DDA
8/3/2012 12:25:05 PM
You are over thinking this. The fact that all religions are basically the same should tell you something. There are over 20 major faiths in today's world and each has meaning to its followers. Enjoy studying the philosophy of religion and see where it goes without putting pressure on yourself to decide today. It’s a journey and a process.
8/5/2012 12:56:45 PM
I appreciate all the comments! I think I'm satisfied now. I was over-analyzing things... how embarrassing! My personality is not like this, so I apologize if I gave the wrong impression. I've been having an existential crisis for the past couple years. I never thought about the big questions in life until I graduated from high school and started working. I think my real question is what do I want to accomplish my life?
8/11/2012 7:12:30 AM
With all kind and caring advice to you Harriett, you must read the Bible's New Testament. Also you must read the Revelation (the end chapter) because it is about the times we live today. The angel's first 'curse' was Hiroshima. The second 'curse' was Nagasaki. The 3rd 'curse' was Chernobyl (the name of the star which fell, and poisoned the air and the waters, and people who drank this water died). The 4th 'curse' was the war of the gulf. We are waiting for the other curses, 7 in total. If you don't believe, and need a miracle to believe, ask for it, and you might have it. Go online and see living people (many....) to whom Jesus has even appeared. But they have a very clean heart, or at other times, they are in need, and desperation, and He comes to save them. Then they went to tell the world, of this favor that happened to them. Also, thank God, that you didn't need so far to fear and worry for your life, and that He gives you health. He provides the health and the life, because He is the life. He will show you, what you need to 'accomplish with your life', as you ask. A Church pastor will answer all your questions, much better than me. Read the Bible and you will see everything happening in real. Because God did not leave us alone. He gave us the New Testament (the 2nd book of the Bible, which is the most relevant to our times). You will find happiness in it and all your questions will be answered!
11/1/2012 1:59:49 PM
Harriett, if you are single, you will like this video I just found. I was so impressed with the advice ‘don’t move ahead of God’s speed and plan for you’. Like a reader comments, I wish too, that I had seen this video earlier. Life would be so happy and successful if two people in a relationship would follow this advice and felt it was the only way. I also liked the thought ‘emotions should not be the boss of our lives’. So often we are led by emotions, making all the mistakes we can, as a result! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mZiLy-mcrA0
DDA
11/2/2012 12:13:05 AM
Thanks for sharing the link, Marcia.
11/3/2012 8:57:10 AM
Isn't it a breath of relief, at the times we are living, when morals have gone down the drain, and we are gradually masterfully led to believe that this is the new way, and the modern times? But like the girl says in the video, yes we change, but God doesn't change, He remains the same He always was. If only we could too, remain, the ones we were back in heaven... Thank you also Dr. Archer for giving me the opportunity to share it here.

Many things happen for a variety of reasons, but we don't see it until later. 2 years ago, I had a new student, she is middle aged though, and not so good in music, because she is into other areas, but nevertheless I started to teach her. Although deep inside, I was always wondering 'what for'. And yet I got my answer, why she came to my path. Obviously not to get lessons from me. The idea is much deeper, and our conversations have made me a better Christian, because she is a wonderful human being, and she is much more Christian than I am. I am there to teach her music, but I receive so much more from her, every lesson becomes for me like a blessing and spiritual progress and this is what God planned. God saw that I am not interested to look for a spiritual progress by myself, and He send her to me as a student, to make sure my eyes stay open! Now we no longer do lessons, perhaps once in 3 months, but the rest of God's plan is working. Wonderful, isn't it?...
Submit a Comment
Name
E-mail  (optional)
Web Site  (optional)
Comment
HTML tags are not allowed.

 

© Copyright 2013, Dr. Archer, Inc.. All rights reserved.